Logo

Should we build on Green Belt land to help solve the housing crisis?

PUBLISHED: 09:33 14 September 2018

Pic: www.gettyimages.co.uk

Pic: www.gettyimages.co.uk

After cabinet minister Liz Truss called for more homes to be built in the countryside, the debate has raged on over whether the government needs to change planning laws to enable this. Property editor Caroline Culot asked two estate agents for their view.

Tim Stephens, Humberts. Pic: www.edp24.co.ukTim Stephens, Humberts. Pic: www.edp24.co.uk

Tim Stephens, Humberts:

‘Building over swathes of our beautiful countryside is not the answer’

Nick Taylor, Hadley Taylor. Pic: www.edp24.co.ukNick Taylor, Hadley Taylor. Pic: www.edp24.co.uk

The Green Belt was a government backed policy to prevent urban sprawl and to protect our precious countryside; a finite commodity. Urban sprawl uses up farmland and wildlife habitats, and increases flood risk, air pollution and car dependency. The concept and policy has to be right, not only for appeasing those NIMBYS (not in my back yard) groups, but also for those townies who walk in and enjoy the leisure and health benefits of the countryside.

Approximately 315 hectares of green fields were built over in the last year – a small percentage (0.02%) of the 1.6m hectares designated as Green Belt. However, facing the current housing crisis and a need to satisfy housing demand – why should not more land be allocated to satisfy demand?

Local Authorities claim to have room for some 720,000 homes on brownfield sites within town centres. If demand equates to say 250,000 new homes a year, a major percentage of the demand is for affordable homes. To help supply, smaller units could be constructed at higher densities, with communal parks for exercise and leisure inside those brownfield sites to help satisfy that demand and conserving the Green Belt. Dropping stamp duty for those empty nesters downsizing, would encourage older couples to move, helping free up more bedrooms and more housing for growing families. This can only be done if there are more retirement homes built and factored into Local Plans.

For the record, about 84% of houses sold on Green Belt land last year were to the middle and upper end of the market. Why are houses for first time buyers not built in the Green Belt? Purely because there is no incentive for the land owner or developer in a profit driven environment. The Local Authorities’ requirement to deliver a percentage as affordable homes as a condition of granting consent recognises this point.

Building over swathes of our beautiful countryside is not the answer, but selective sites in the Green Belt, such as non=productive land, pig buildings, redundant nissen huts, chicken houses etc should be considered for development. With transport links, these small communities will provide a hub for young families who will support the local school, the church, the village shop and the pub and restore the backbone of our rural life.”

Nick Taylor, Hadley Taylor and chairman of the NDAEA, Norwich & District Association of Estate Agents:

‘It’s time this government got a grip on the true nature of our housing requirements and stopped pandering to vested interest groups,’

Liz Truss is the latest in a long line of politicians to suggest that building houses on the green belt is necessary to solve the housing crisis. The Member of Parliament for South West Norfolk thinks that building thousands of new homes in the countryside is the answer to all our housing problems. Firstly, I don’t agree that there is a housing crisis and I certainly don’t agree that building houses in the countryside is a good idea.

House builders, of course, love building houses in the countryside because it’s easier than building them in towns and cities on brown field sites and so they make more profit. Profit being the primary and probably the sole driver for any house builder they would build houses on green fields all day long if they got the chance. House builders form a very powerful business lobby and this is why ministers continually suggest concreting over the green belt.

The reason it’s such folly to build anything in the countryside comes down to our need to protect the environment. We are told that unless we get a grip on CO2 emissions during the next 20 to 30 years we are going to have to deal with the consequences of an over-heated planet, parts of which are going to become increasingly uninhabitable. Therefore, any new homes must be built in towns and cities in close proximity to jobs, schools and other amenities. Most new homes today are built in out of town locations with at least two cars parked outside each house. Here in Norfolk the vast majority of residents in new houses converge in their cars on the nearest town or to Norwich on a daily basis. This is clearly not desirable from a traffic congestion point of view and it certainly conflicts totally with the Government’s supposed commitment to the Paris accord on climate change.

There are other practical issues such as lack of public services, school places, broadband access, electricity generation capacity, mains gas supply and water resources, to name but a few, that make big out of town housing developments totally unsustainable.

So why do we need houses in the countryside? We don’t. We need some homes in urban areas and these should be small, efficient and affordable units. The sole reason we need more houses in the first place is because successive governments think it’s a good idea to increase our population. It’s time this government got a grip on the true nature of our housing requirements and stopped pandering to vested interest groups.

What do you think? Email caroline.culot@archant.co.uk

Latest Property Articles

This mid terraced house was bought at auction last year and the owners have completely renovated it, transforming it inside, and have now put it back on the market for sale for a guide price of £595,000.

The landlord of a squalid block of city flats told his sales agent to report tenants who complained so he could kick them out.

If you like the idea of really being by the sea, you might like to view a new development based on the site of a former convent right opposite the beach and sea. Property editor Caroline Culot went to visit St Mary’s in Lowestoft where homes are for sale with Aldreds ranging from £160,000 to £400,000.I grew up by the sea just a bit further down the coast and I absolutely adore the sound of the waves crashing. There’s nothing like a bracing walk on the beach in the winter for clearing your head. And, there’s something really rewarding about braving the water and having a swim in the summer - even more rewarding is the hot chocolate afterwards to get the feeling back in your fingers and toes! So, I relished an invitation to see this new development of 20 homes which have been built by Cripps Developments on Rectory Road literally a pebble’s throw from the seafront and beach. Ten properties have already been sold leaving 10 available ranging from a one bedroom ground floor apartment to a three/five bedroom end terraced house.

Tom Amis of Savills’ Norwich-based new homes team reflects on the market.

Spire Solicitors LLP are pleased to announce they have been shortlisted for two national awards to celebrate their achievements after another successful year. The awards are a part of LawNet and follow on from the firm being crowned Law Firm of the Year in 2017/2018.

Natalie Briggs, conveyancing executive at Spire Solicitors LLP, takes a look at the stamp duty implications when purchasing a property with an annexe.

Are you renting out a room of your house? Tax expert Jon Hook, from Norwich Accountancy Services, discusses ‘rent a room relief.’

How are new homes being built to reflect our changing lifestyles? Edward Parker from Bennett Homes, discusses.

How will the rental sector be affected by the impact of last week’s budget? Mike White, from Martin & Co in Norwich discusses.

A family have told of their shock after developers on their housing estate left their car completely covered in mud and started working at 6.30am at weekends.

Some may fear the housing market is slowing but not in East Anglia where two of the biggest country estates have sold: Sutton Hall Estate for well in excess of its £31.5 million price tag and Lodge Farm, part of the Riddlesworth Estate, Gasthorpe, which sold for around £9.5 million.

The NR31 postcode area - covering locations like Yarmouth, Gorleston and Bradwell continues to be where the most homes sold in the whole of Norfolk and Suffolk over the past few months, according to a new report.

Plans have been submitted to build nearly 200 more homes in an ever expanding Norfolk village.

Residents have submitted more than 230 objections to a planning application to build 148 homes in Norfolk.

The former Start-rite shoe factory site in Norwich could finally be redeveloped more than a decade after it closed.

A charity that helps disadvantaged young people is selling one of its Edwardian properties in Norwich for £850,000.

Your home in the east of England could be worth on average 9.3 per cent more in 2023 - but this is not as much as areas in the north which could see values soar by over 21 per cent, a new report highlights today.

This Grade II listed house, which dates in part as far back as the early 1500s, is architecturally exceptional but it has been given a complete make-over by the current vendors who have improved it and dressed it with the most beautiful interiors. Property editor Caroline Culot enjoyed a visit to see Knapton Old Hall, for sale for £1.35 million.

Don’t abandon your conservatory this winter – warm it up, instead.

They spend their working day creating beautiful, sought-after spaces for their clients – but when it comes to their own homes, what are some of Norfolk’s interior designers’ favourite rooms?

Winter’s just around the corner so, to help keep you warm and cosy, we asked Oliver Murphy, retail operations manager at Gasway, to answer some home heating questions.

TV racing presenter and a former jockey, Emma Spencer is selling her palatial Newmarket home. EDP property editor Caroline Culot went to visit The Courtyard, Balaton Place, for sale for a guide price of £3.5 million.

The bid to revamp Norwich’s Anglia Square has been dealt a potential blow, after watchdog Historic England lodged a fresh objection and signalled it would take its battle to stop the scheme to the government.

A Grade II listed farmhouse needing complete renovation went under the hammer for £480,000 today at auction. Here are the full results.

A decision over the future of the site of the Eastern Daily Press and Norwich Evening News’s Prospect House is due to be made by city councillors next week.

What once was an office block on Prince of Wales Road in Norwich is now a plush apartment development brought to the city by Regency Residential and more than half way to being completely sold out. So what do these one, two and three bedroom homes at Grosvenor House, ranging in price from £154,375 to £284,950, have to offer?

We buy with our eyes and nothing sells a house more than evocative photographs. But when a house is completely empty, how do you sell that all important concept, a lifestyle? Nick Eley, a partner at Watsons, can help you.

Developers are preparing proposals to build 600 homes and a petrol station just off the main road through Bradwell.

It began as a pension project but 14 long years later, the renovation of Aylsham’s watermill is finally complete and the third and last property is up for sale. Property editor Caroline Culot went to take a look at Wagtail, for sale for a guide price of £625,000.

Hidden away in the heart of Wells-Next-The-Sea is the most beautiful Grade II listed Georgian former rectory. Its structure is divine and it has been renovated and dressed in a contemporary style. Property editor Caroline Culot had the privilege of visiting The Old Rectory, Church Street.

If you’re a fan of golf, this could be your dream home, a property for sale overlooking the course and right next to the clubhouse!

Buy this house which dates to 1580, the reign of Elizabeth I and full of original features like mullioned windows and exposed timbers.

A student accommodation block and disused car park could be demolished in Norwich city centre.

Recently returned to Norfolk from London, the newest member of Savills’ residential sales team, Polly Hughes, focuses on the powerful pull of life in and around Norwich.

Historic England has raised concern over proposals for 30 new homes next to the remains of a 15th century lodge in Drayton.

Fancy doing a self-build but got limited funds? You can do on a smaller scale, says Ron Beattie, of Beattie Passive.

What are all the ‘hidden’ costs developers have to pay when building new homes? Tony Abel, of Abel Homes, explains the expense of building homes which many people are unaware of.

Your home in Norfolk went up in value in August - with areas of Breckland going up by the most, and by the least in the west of the county, new figures show.

Thousands of new homes are going to be built in Norwich and its surrounding areas over the coming years.

A late 16th century townhouse in the centre of Norwich is for sale for £425,000 where not one, but two famous heroines were born.

It’s no surprise that some areas of Norwich command higher house prices than others but where do you get the most for your money? Property editor Caroline Culot looks at what you can buy for £200,000, well under the cost of the average property, £271,257, in the city.

It once was the site of an old bungalow but now it’s a sensational new home with a price tag to match. Property editor Caroline Culot went to visit The Smithy, New Road, Blakeney.

Hundreds of homes could be built near Thorpe St Andrew as new plans emerge for land next to the Norwich Northern Distributor Road (NDR).

A dream of building their own home along with up to 14 more houses got a step closer for Norfolk couple Kevin and Karen Keable when the first day of construction was marked by a ground-breaking ceremony.

A private outdoor swimming pool in Sprowston could be made available to the public.

Meet the Editor

Caroline Culot

Email
Twitter

I am the property editor in charge of delivering some exciting and informative content within Archant’s varied titles. We have 16-17 pages of stories, features and columns in the EDP Property supplement out every Friday free in your EDP so please don’t miss it.