Deposit Replacement Schemes - should landlords embrace or beware?

PUBLISHED: 20:32 09 June 2018

Pic: www.gettyimages.co.uk

Pic: www.gettyimages.co.uk

In the wake of the up and coming tenant fee ban, currently trundling its way through parliament, so called ‘Deposit Replacement schemes’ are popping up all over the place in the lettings market. Mike White, from Martin & Co, tells us more.

Mike White, Martin & Co. Pic: www.edp24.co.ukMike White, Martin & Co. Pic: www.edp24.co.uk

If you haven’t seen them yet, you will; not least because the government has taken notice of a select committee’s recommendations “and will encourage further innovation in the deposit free renting sector”.

There’s a number of different variations on the theme but broadly speaking what happens is that a tenant, instead of having to find, say, a month and a half’s worth of rent, as a security deposit, pays the equivalent of a week or so’s rent to provide their new landlord with an insurance policy covering any dilapidations to the property during their tenancy. The theory is if the landlord does need money to put things right at the end of the tenancy, the insurer coughs up and then goes to the tenant for reimbursement. The tenant is obliged to pay and if they don’t then the insurer pursues them through the court system.

Sounds fantastic doesn’t it – the landlord gets their money and the tenant doesn’t have to find a hefty security deposit upfront, not seeing it again until the end of the tenancy. So, along with paying no agent fees, for a few hundred pounds, they’ll be able to move into your house. What could possibly go wrong?

The reason some agents are so keen on them, particularly the corporate agents, is that they get a big wedge of the ‘few hundred pounds’ paid back to them as a commission payment. There are many agents up and down the country who have structured their whole being around offering cheap deals to landlords and recouping the cost of doing business by whacking tenants with big fees. Come the fee ban, those agents are going to have a bit of a problem unless they can replace the lost revenue.

So, let’s have a quick look at the plus and minus points from a tenant perspective. For good and bad tenants’ alike, there’s the obvious advantage of not having to stump up so much at the outset. However, for the good tenant who pays their rent and leaves the property as they found it, while they would previously have received their entire deposit back, a deposit replacement scheme will cost them a non-refundable fee. Many of these schemes require the tenant to pay an ongoing monthly fee as well, so if the tenancy lasts for a couple of years or more, this will cost them dear in the long run.

For the tenant who leaves a mess or damages the property, they’ll still be required to cough up the remediation costs in full just as they would if they had put up a security deposit. But, it’ll have cost them the same fees as for the good tenant and should they choose not to pay for the dilapidations, then it will definitely be a case of ‘See You in Court’, since no insurer will take that laying down.

What about for the landlord? Well there’s the argument that they’ll be more potential tenants for your property as fewer people will be ‘priced out’. On the other hand, without that commitment of putting up a real deposit, they’re not going to think they have any ‘skin in the game’, so will they look after the property quite so well? I’d 
also be concerned about the length of time it took for the scheme provider/insurer to pay out the damages at the end of the tenancy. While the current Deposit Protection Schemes can be slow, at least the process is well established and, moreover, if a deposit dispute goes to adjudication, you know that it will be done fairly and independently.

Since I was taught to be cautious and am much more of a risk manager than just someone trying to flog you landlord services and products at every opportunity, I will be very wary of these schemes until they are proven beyond doubt. Hence, you won’t see Martin & Co Norwich marketing them as the next best thing. For now, cash will remain King!

For more information and for a better understanding of deposit replacement schemes, give Mike White a call at Martin & Co Norwich, column sponsors, on 01603 766860.

Latest Property Articles

The £45m revamp of two huge towers in the heart of Norwich into homes for 700 students is on track to be completed by September next year.

Time is running out for people to have their say on where thousands of new homes could be built in and around Norwich over the next two decades.

Plans have been lodged to create a seven-bed student shared house in Norwich.

Council bosses looking to build houses and, potentially, a swimming pool in Norwich are facing a race to get the site decontaminated or they could have to pay almost £1m back to the government.

A Norfolk group chief executive has criticised ‘ridiculous’ lending criteria after he was forced to pull out of buying a city centre penthouse because he could not get a mortgage.

Reports in the national press over the last few months have highlighted a slow-down in the housing market during these uncertain times of Brexit negotiations. However, demand for new homes in East Anglia remains strong. Edward Parker, from Bennett Homes, discusses.

If you are thinking about selling your home in the New Year, you may want to make sure you have the right paperwork, records and certificates in place in order to make the process smoother. Being prepared for any potential enquiries will help to avoid delays along the way. Sharron Tennant, from Spire solicitors, discusses.

Looming on the horizon are some most unwelcome changes in the way that UK taxpayers will have to report and pay for capital gains tax (CGT) on residential properties in the future. Jon Hook, managing director at Norwich Accountancy Services, discusses.

A team of volunteers is sought to help celebrate the history of Anglia Square, after a community project was awarded a National Lottery grant of more than £50,000.

Since its Christmas – well nearly – and we haven’t had much cheer this year what with Brexit and all, here for your mild amusement is a lettings version of the 12 Days of Christmas, says Mike White from Martin & Co lettings in Norwich.

William H Brown held its last auction of the year yesterday at the Barnham Broom hotel. Managing director and auctioneer, Simon Arnes, reports on the firm’s sale.

The controversial plans to develop Norwich’s Anglia Square have been given the go-ahead and here’s a first look at what new homes in the development could look like.

The humble bungalow was once considered the house type that style forgot. But not any more. And with more people living longer and less bungalows being built, single storey dwellings have never been more popular. Whatever would Granny say?

The developer behind the £271m Anglia Square revamp has likened the scheme to Marmite - conceding that some people will hate it.

The controversial £271m redevelopment of Norwich’s Anglia Square has been approved by city councillors.

It would be an “abomination” if the £271m Anglia Square revamp is given the go-ahead, the Lord Mayor of Norwich has said, as councillors get ready to make a decision on the controversial scheme.

A family that had threatened to stage a protest at a Norfolk housing development over fears they could be homeless at Christmas have finally been promised the keys to their new home.

A decision on whether to grant permission for one of the most contentious and biggest planning applications Norwich has seen for years will be made today.

The controversial revamp of Norwich’s Anglia Square has the potential to create more than 500 new jobs, while people living in the new homes could spend up to £40m a year, council officers have said.

Designer Wayne Hemingway has joined the debate over the £271m plans for Anglia Square, urging city councillors to reject the proposals.

An estate agent who had to pull out of a city centre office said she has enjoyed her ‘best year ever’ at premises in the suburbs - as the debate continues over whether businesses are being driven out of Norwich.

A call for the government to make the final decision if councillors grant permission for the £271m Anglia Square revamp has been backed by civic watchdog the Norwich Society.

A fresh bid has been lodged over the future use of Norwich’s Grade II-listed Crystal House - and to build nine homes behind the back of the historic building.

Norwich is in danger of losing business investment because of a shortage of good quality commercial premises and an increasing number of road closures.

In today’s fast paced and technology driven society, it is essential to market your property in the most effective way, with the widest exposure. Sheron Harley, managing director of the Property Shop, discusses.

Developers behind plans for Norwich’s Anglia Square are hoping to be excused from paying almost £9m, if their proposals get the go-ahead.

Are you looking to sell a property quickly? Auction House, with four sale rooms in East Anglia, has the answer.

Hardwick House, one of the most impressive buildings in Norwich which is currently empty and boarded up, could become a pub as it goes up for rental after its £1.6 million sale falls through.

The controversial £271m proposal to revamp Norwich’s Anglia Square has been recommended for approval.

A controversial move to excuse some developers in Norwich from paying a levy of thousands of pounds is crucial if sites are not to stand derelict, council leaders have insisted.

More than £1m is to be spent to turn a block of offices into seven council homes.

‘Brexit is Brexit and people still want to move’ - that was the message from estate agents working in Norfolk and Suffolk who declare 2018 has been a better year for sales than 2017 despite new gloomy figures showing a 12 per cent fall in transactions.

He spent last winter homeless and on the streets but this Christmas a Norwich man will have a roof over his head after he has been helped by a charity.

Despite house prices rising, the number of properties sold has fallen; down by 12 per cent in Norfolk and 8 per cent in Suffolk compared with the same period last year, new figures reveal.

Important news for future house hunters contained in October’s budget was that the government’s Help to Buy scheme is to be extended – but only until 2023.

If you’re thinking about selling part of your garden land for development, there are several things to consider. Carolyn Bunn, from Spire Solicitors, discusses.

It is one of the most contentious and biggest planning applications Norwich has seen for years - the revamp of Anglia Square - and a decision is just weeks away. How did we get to this point? And what is being planned? Dan Grimmer reports.

A Norfolk couple who are house builders have won a national award at a ceremony likened to the ‘Oscars of the construction industry.’

It is a derelict, fire-hit site that has been sitting empty for a decade in Thorpe St Andrew.

Plans have been submitted to Norwich City Council to create a 10 bedroom house.

From bringing ‘ghost’ ponds back to life, to environmentally switched-on schoolchildren and energy-efficient social housing - projects in Norfolk have been celebrated with awards.

What’s the importance to a firm of feedback? Ben Rivett, of Savills’ Norwich residential team, discusses.

Situated at the end of a no-through road, you would never have reason to find this magnificent house, originally the home of an esteemed Norwich coroner. And yes, it really is on a hill! Property editor Caroline Culot had the joy of visiting Hill House in Bramerton, for sale for £2.5million.

From controversy to accolade - a Norwich housing development is up for an award.

Meet the Editor

Caroline Culot


I am the property editor in charge of delivering some exciting and informative content within Archant’s varied titles. We have 16-17 pages of stories, features and columns in the EDP Property supplement out every Friday free in your EDP so please don’t miss it.