Workers may have less privacy than they think on the job

 <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
(Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Workers may have less privacy than they think on the job.

Employers are using surveillance tools like CCTV, keystroke logging, and message monitoring to track employee activity on company devices and systems, raising questions about where the line should be drawn between legitimate oversight and a breach of privacy.

Natalie Peacock, an employment expert at Rogers and Norton in Norwich, said: "The law generally permits employers to monitor staff using methods ranging from CCTV cameras and vehicle trackers to email monitoring.

"However, workers are entitled to privacy, dignity and data protection rights.

"Employers must be able to justify any monitoring and surveillance they carry out."

The warning comes as the government consults on whether stronger measures are needed to make workplace monitoring more transparent, fair and accountable.

From tracking website visits and keyboard activity to reading chat messages on platforms like Microsoft Teams, workplace surveillance can cover a wide range of behaviours—often without employees fully realising what data is being collected or how it might be used.

Ms Peacock said: "A company can track an employee’s keyboard activity to measure productivity, but the monitoring must comply with data protection law and respect the employee’s right to privacy.

"Workers must be told about the monitoring, including its purpose, the data being collected and how it will be used."

She explained that keystroke logging and similar tools are considered high-risk data processing, meaning employers may need to carry out a Data Protection Impact Assessment before introducing such measures.

Even messages marked “private” on platforms like Teams or Slack may not be off-limits.

Ms Peacock said: "Employers should only read private messages in compliance with data protection laws and human rights principles to avoid potential claims of constructive dismissal or a breach of privacy rights."

Employers may also be able to take screenshots of work devices, potentially capturing messages, documents, or websites open at that moment.

She said: "Occasional monitoring may include random screenshots taken as a short-term measure to address a specific need.

"It will only be permissible if it is a legitimate effort to monitor productivity or prevent misuse of IT systems."

The same principles apply to remote workers, though there are additional considerations.

Ms Peacock said: "Employers are entitled to monitor people working from home when they are using company equipment.

"The key difference is the heightened expectation of privacy.

"The home inherently involves a greater expectation of privacy, and automatic webcam monitoring or similarly intrusive methods are likely to be disproportionate and unjustifiable."

Most of the time, employees should be informed about monitoring, including what data is being collected and why.

Ms Peacock said: "Covert monitoring is only permissible in exceptional circumstances, such as when there is a genuine suspicion of criminal activity.

"Even then, it should be narrowly targeted and used only for a temporary period."

Data collected through lawful and well-communicated monitoring policies can be used in disciplinary proceedings.

Ms Peacock said: "As long as employees have been made aware of their employer’s monitoring policies, data collected through those practices can be used in disciplinary proceedings.

"Employers should have clear monitoring and disciplinary policies that explain their right to capture data and use it as evidence."

However, monitoring can cross the line if it becomes excessive or intrudes on areas where employees have a reasonable expectation of privacy.

Ms Peacock said: "Excessive or disproportionate monitoring, particularly in toilets or of private communications, may breach employees’ rights as well as the implied duty of trust and confidence.

"If that breach causes an employee to resign, the employer may face a constructive dismissal claim."

She advised workers who feel their privacy has been violated to review their contract and company policies, raise an internal grievance, speak to their union, or seek external advice.

Ms Peacock said: "Employees can also make a Data Subject Access Request to see the personal information their employer has collected about them."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos