Customers fear a city baker who promised to "make things right" will simply repeat the cycle that left them out of pocket.
Those who have bought from Terry Bakes - run by Terry Pegler - are worried he will repeat previous actions of taking online orders, then failing to deliver them because the backlog is unmanageable.
Mr Pegler sparked outrage after announcing on social media that he would not fulfil existing orders and telling customers to seek chargebacks from their banks, as he could not issue refunds.
Terry Pegler, the man behind Terry Bakes (Image: Instagram: @terrybakesuk)
In a later video shared to Instagram, Mr Pegler then said he would be opening up orders by baking "some cakes" to earn money so that "in a couple of weeks", he could start fulfilling orders for his customers regardless of whether they received a chargeback.
But Mr Pegler then U-turned in another video, saying he was "not sure going back and selling cakes is the right thing to do right now".
It comes as more than a dozen people have complained to Trading Standards about the city baker's delays and refusal to issue refunds.
Sue Walker, 60, who placed an order on behalf of her son in May, said: "If he’s got money to bake, he’s got money to refund his customers. I and other customers are not happy. In fact the consensus is everyone is livid.
Sue Walker, who lives in Chelmsford, is one of the customers who has lodged a complaint with Trading Standards (Image: Sue Walker)
"Hopefully the word is out there now. People have seen through him, even some of his most loyal followers have turned on him.”
Gina Colloff, who ordered a mystery box last year and waited six weeks for it to arrive, said: "Please don't order from Terry Bakes. He has already let down thousands of customers."
Gina Colloff (Image: Gina Colloff)
What's next, Terry?
In response to the concerns, Mr Pegler has asked for "space to consider and provide the answers everyone wants".
He said: "After a period of reflection I’m putting a plan together with my advisors to address everyone's concerns.
"I'd just ask people to give me a little time to work out the best course for everyone. My family have been subjected to abuse and distress that no one deserves and it’s taken an enormous toll on their mental and physical health.
Terry Pegler during his Bake Away days (Image: Jamie Honeywood)
"I want to address everyone’s concerns in due course and my own failings but at present I just need to protect and support my family while I receive help to understand a way forward.
"I will continue to create and I hope entertain going forward but at present I’m unable to make any further comment while we work on our future.
"I would like to thank the thousands of people who have reached out to encourage me going forward, and I hope to have more news soon."
Help for customers
The controversy surrounding Terry Bakes has attracted attention from a number of online baking celebrities, some of whom have offered to help Mr Pegler's out of pocket customers.
One baker, Rich Myers, who founded Get Baked an online bakery which delivers across the country, has offered to send anyone who has ordered from Terry Bakes £50 worth of goods if they spend £25 with Mr Myers' business.
He said on an Instagram post: "I realise this this means spending even more money, and I get that lots of people won't want to do that but ultimately you'll have spent £50, and received £50 worth of goods for free."
Customers have also rallied online, including through a Facebook page known as Operation Stop the Beglers.
Sam, 51, who runs the page and asked to be identified only by her first name, said: “I realised there are going to be people who do not know what to do about this so the page offers information on how they can get chargebacks or even if they just want to speak about their experience. I just want to help people.”
An online petition has also emerged, which has gathered 184 signatures.
The petition is calling for a review that stops content creators from earning money through their social media platforms when they can no longer fulfil paid orders.
Customers with further complaints are being urged to contact the Citizens Advice consumer helpline on 0808 223 1133 for advice on seeking redress.
Share