Norwich Philharmonic under fire over Russian concert plans

8
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Norfolk's leading orchestra is embroiled in an extraordinary row over its plans for a concert featuring music by Russian composers.

Ukrainians living in the county have accused the Norwich Philharmonic Society of a "profound lack of empathy" and of promoting Russian "soft power" by staging the event against the backdrop of the war in their country.

Norwich Philharmonic Orchestra (Image: Bill Smith)

The concert was originally promoted using the tagline "Russian Fireworks" and while the orchestra has agreed to stop using the phrase, it is still facing calls to scrap the evening altogether.

However, others have defended the concert online, saying it does not represent an endorsement of the current Russian regime.

The event is due to be held at the events centre at the Norfolk Showground on February 14 and will feature works by 20th century composers Sergei Prokofiev and Sergei Rachmaninov.

The backlash began after the orchestra announced the details on Facebook, with local Ukrainians posting their criticism.

Inna Drozdenko (Image: Facebook)

One wrote: "When Russia launches its 'fireworks' daily at Ukrainian cities, using this title is not 'art outside politics'. It is blindness.

"If the Philharmonic wants to understand what a real Russian Firework looks like, why not take a guided tour of Ukrainian cities?

"Is it appropriate to enjoy the culture of a country that is actively destroying another culture?"

Inna Drozdenko, who came to Norfolk from Ukraine in May 2022 following the Russian invasion of her country, is among those campaigning for the concert to be cancelled.

Alexander Ullman (Image: Supplied)

"The issue is not just about the title, but the entire context of promoting a 'mighty Russian' program during the ongoing war.

"It feels like they are normalising the promotion of Russian culture.

"Renaming, rebranding, or reframing the concert, does not resolve the ethical issue."

The advert as first seen on Facebook (Image: Inna Drozdenko)

"This is not just about art; it’s about the ethics of cultural soft power during a war."

Catrina Nixon, vice chairwoman of the orchestra, said the phrase "Russian Fireworks" had been "simply referring to the exuberance of the particular works in what happens to be an all-Russian programme".

"As soon as we realised that this expression was causing offence to our Ukrainian community we changed it," she added. 

She insisted the concert, featuring British pianist Alexander Ullman, would go ahead, adding: "Norwich Philharmonic Society recognises the ongoing tragic and distressing situation in Ukraine and we are sorry that the headline promoting this concert online has caused upset.

The current promotional content for the show (Image: Norwich Philharmonic)

"The wording was intended to celebrate the quality of the music and nothing more.

"Programming concerts with works by Russian composers who died over 70 years ago does not imply any support for the current regime or its actions.

"Indeed both Rachmaninov and Prokofiev had complicated relationships with Russia, living significant parts of their lives in exile; in general the musical and artistic world is making the distinction between this and, for example, not engaging Russian artists who have expressed support for the current regime and/or its actions in Ukraine.

The events centre at the Norfolk Showground (Image: Denise Bradley)

"Music composed by Russian composers from the past continues to be performed widely under this premise."

She said that the orchestra would be collecting donations at the concert for the Supporting Ukraine in Norfolk Fund.

However, Ms Drozdenko, an IT recruiter, remains unhappy with the response.

"This is about the security of the UK and Europe. Using a 'Mighty Russian' brand to sell tickets while that same state is a direct threat to our shared security is a dangerous normalisation."

She accused the orchestra of ignoring the points she had raised.

"It seems they have no answer to the concern they are using cultural 'soft power' as a marketing tool during an active war," she said.

"Distinguishing between 'culture' and 'regime' is a luxury that people under bombardment do not have."

Sergei Prokofiev (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

Rachmaninoff (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

The Philharmonic, which was set up in 1841, has a full-size symphony orchestra and a mixed chorus of some 120 voices.

It performs four concerts of choral and/or orchestral music each season, with occasional children’s concerts, plus a family Christmas concert.

Next month's event features Prokofiev's Third and Rachmaninov's First Symphony.

It will open with a work by another Russian, Mikhail Glinka.

The orchestra will perform the Overture to his opera Ruslan and Ludmila.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos