Poll: Pinebanks plans advised for approval ahead of committee decision - do you agree?

PUBLISHED: 12:00 21 February 2013 | UPDATED: 15:57 21 February 2013

The vacant Pinebanks site in Thorpe St Andrew. Photo: Andy Darnell

The vacant Pinebanks site in Thorpe St Andrew. Photo: Andy Darnell

Archant © 2011

Controversial plans for more than 260 new homes in Thorpe St Andrew look to have moved a step closer to becoming reality – but defiant campaigners said today they were not giving up their fight.

The proposals for 215 homes at Pinebanks, the former Norwich Union sports ground, and 52 homes in Griffin Lane are set to go before Broadland District Council’s planning committee next Wednesday.

A report prepared for the committee by council officers has been published ahead of the meeting and is advising the councillors to approve the proposals.

The site has now been left empty for five years and Berliet Ltd have been planning to develop the site since December 2009.

Mike Riches, spokesman for the Friends of Thorpe St Andrew (FOTSA) campaign group, said he was “surprised” the plans had been recommended for approval.

Pinebanks history

February 2008 – Members of Pinebanks informed by Norwich Union, now Aviva, that the site would be shutting. Members told the site is worth almost £500,000 in real estate and over 30 sport socieites are immediately left searching for a new home.

December 2009 – It emerges Jersey-based Berliet Ltd have purchased the Pinebanks site from Norwich Union, although the company insists it has no firm plans and the site may not be developed for five years.

November 2010 – Local residents join forces with Norwich North MP Chloe Smith and district councillors to make clear to Berliet Ltd’s development manager, Ocubis, that provision for sports facilities were included in any plans.

January 2012 – Broadland District Council head of planning Phil Courtier warned any Pinebanks development would be unacceptable were new facilities not equal to those lost when the site closed in 2008.

May 2012 – Ocubis reveals its plans for 215 homes at Pinebanks, alongside 52 homes at Griffin Lane. and reveals a ‘sports hub’ which would create new sport facilities, including a skate park and cricket training facilities, and bring redundant football pitches back into use.

FOTSA have been campaigning to try and ensure sports facilities lost on the Pinebanks site will be replaced and Mr Riches, who lives in Henby Way, is not giving up hope of Broadland’s planning committee going against the recommendation.

He cited comments from Sport England in the report, which state “the proposal fails to meet” the organisation’s playing field policy.

Mr Riches said: “The sporting aspect is the biggest thing that we have been campaigning for and I still think the sports hub being proposed is not going to work.

“The council needs to make sure the developers do replace what’s being lost for our future generations.

“How many kids are becoming obese has been in the news and it’s frightening. Whenever I go abroad every village seems to have a sports pitch, but we seem to have our priorities wrong in this country.”

Development managers Ocubis, working on behalf of Berliet Ltd, have attempted to compensate for the loss of the Pinebanks facilities by pledging several planning agreements.

These include £997,000 towards a new sports facility at Thorpe St Andrew School, which would have public opening hours and for which there is also pre-existing planning permission.

This also includes £25,000 for reinstating two football pitches at Dussindale Recreation Ground and £80,000 towards a skate park, while £400,000 would contribute towards a new town council community facilitiy.

Three members of the public have so far requested to speak about Pinebanks at the committee meeting next Wednesday. Anyone else wanting to speak must contact the council by 5pm tomorrow.

- Do you think the plans should be approved? Cast your vote in the poll above and leave your comments below.

Related articles

Latest Property Articles

A petition calling for housing to only be built where it is easily accessible by foot or by public transport is to be launched today.

They were legends of their day. The riders who roared around the city’s speedway track, cheered on by as many fans as now pack into Carrow Road to watch Norwich City.

David Wilson Homes built 517 homes in the Eastern Counties last year, contributing over £85.1m to the economy, a new report reveals.

If you get divorced, what happens to the family home? Sarb Gosal, partner at Spire Solicitors LLP, gives you the legal lowdown.

A common area of confusion among property owners is the distinction between legal and beneficial ownership and the corresponding tax treatment of each.

2018 is a great year to buy a new property, says Edward Parker from Bennett Homes

It’s an opportunity that sounds like something from a game of Monopoly.

Bovis Homes has become the latest housebuilder to shrug off economic uncertainty by posting a bullish trading update, pointing to a hefty rise in profit this year.

From prime offices and new homes to industrial estates and top shops, we can today reveal the properties in Norfolk and Suffolk bought by companies in offshore tax havens.

A closed Norwich pub is to be turned into flats for students.

A developer is proposing to build 205 new properties in Rackheath - across the road from a 3,000-home extension to the village.

One of Norwich’s landmark buildings, Hardwick House, is on the market and an offer has already been made close to the £1.6million price tag.

The public can now have their say on where they think more than 7,000 homes should be built in Norfolk.

An apartment has gone on sale at the former Norfolk & Norwich Hospital with fantastic night-time views

More than £2m is to be spent to improve the safety of hundreds of people living in Norwich’s tower blocks, in the wake of the Grenfell Tower fire.

A mystery buyer has made an offer on a former ironmongers in Aylsham - with contracts due to exchange shortly

Members of the NDAEA donated £1000 to a homeless charity in Norwich.

A “dangerous” village crossroads could be replaced with a roundabout as part of a proposed new housing development.

The prospect of a new garden village in Norfolk has been mooted, as council bosses wrestle with where more than 7,000 more homes should be built in the county.

More than 50 new homes could be built in a South Norfolk village.

More than 20 new homes could be built on land owned by Broadland District Council in Great Plumstead.

Builders could lose the right to create a new 140-home housing estate unless an extension to its planning permission is granted.

Will this be the year when work finally begins on a number of stalled Norwich schemes where several hundred new homes are planned?

As the future for Norwich’s Anglia Square is cast into the spotlight with news of revised proposals for the area’s regeneration, this paper is calling for 2018 to be the year of positive change for the north city location.

Up to 93 new homes could be built next door to Norwich City Hockey Club’s grounds in Taverham.

A London-based property developer is seeking to build up to 550 homes near Thorpe St Andrew.

Joe Pattinson, Newbury New Homes, discusses the real cost of stamp duty

Well as it’s almost time for the dreaded staff Christmas outing. I’ve warned my family and my liver to expect the worse, says Keith Hood, of Warners Financial Services.

Why do we put up with such an archaic house buying and selling system, asks Andrew Pointen, of Pointens.

Concern has been raised that the sudden surge in bids to build student flats in Norwich is happening without a proper strategy to see if they are needed.

If you are thinking of purchasing your first home or moving house, it is important to understand all of the costs involved before you start house-hunting. Your solicitor will handle the legal work around the property, however, there are some extra costs involved within the conveyancing process. When planning your budget we would advise you to consider:

There are many elements to a self-build project to take into account, and overlooking any of them could cost you time and precious funds. Most of us only think of the obvious of design, build and construction, but there are also a few more unusual responsibilities that you need to be aware of, from site access to drinking water.

Controversial plans to build more than 280 student flats are on a Norwich car park have been rejected, after neighbours made pleas for the scheme to be turned down.

Whichever way round it is, I generally try to avoid watching this genre of TV programme for the simple reason that I work long hours anyway and this would be like taking work home with me. But the other day, in a weak moment, I found myself watching one about the older couple who, needing to supplement their pensions, bought an eight-bedroom HMO (House in Multiple Occupation) in a generally high-yielding rental town (aka economically challenged).

A city centre apartment block is charging £15,000 for parking spaces as it sells almost 200 new homes.

A decision will be made next week over whether more than 280 student flats can be built on a Norwich car park - with neighbours urging councillors to turn the application down.

Campaigning Costessey residents are delighted after a highly-contentious plan for 83 homes in the River Tud Valley was unanimously rejected by councillors.

We’ve mapped the latest price paid data from the Land Registry Office to give a snapshot of the Norfolk property market.

A controversial plan for 83 homes in a river valley has been recommended for approval despite attracting hundreds of objections.

He was immortalised in a song by The Beatles and has a blue plaque commemorating him, but now one of Norwich’s most celebrated Victorians is to lend his name to a new tower taking shape in the city.

Norwich has been named one of the top property hot spots of the year.

The chancellor’s autumn budget delivered on November 22 focused very much on boosting the UK’s productivity and building greater self-sufficiency given the UK’s impending exit from the EU, states Jon Hook, from Norwich Accountancy Services.

The properties may have closed, but controversy surrounding two former MJB hotels in Norwich continues.

Multi-million pound bids have been lodged to kick-start two major Norwich developments of hundreds of homes.

Meet the Editor

Caroline Culot


I am the property editor in charge of delivering some exciting and informative content within Archant’s varied titles. We have 16-17 pages of stories, features and columns in the EDP Property supplement out every Friday free in your EDP so please don’t miss it.